The Customer Is not Always Right – Believing Otherwise Will Kill Profit Margins
Pain Points This Article Addresses
- Losing money on unreasonable customers with unrealistic expectations
- Destroying employee morale when service teams must accommodate every customer
- Business owners wasting resources on clients who damage customer satisfaction metrics
- Customer service teams burning out from unreasonable demands
- Being held hostage by customers who often threaten bad reviews to get their way
- Many businesses underpricing because difficult clients always demand discounts
The $250,000 Lesson: A Customer is not Always Right
Picture this: It’s 2004, I’m running a manufacturing business in Australia, and my biggest client represents 35% of my revenue. They know it. I know it. And they’re wrong about using it like a weapon against my business.
Every week brings new customer requests that cross professional boundaries. Free rush deliveries. Impossible deadlines. Constant threats. My employees need stability, but this abusive customer is creating chaos. Yet I kept thinking, “the customer is always right,” right?
Wrong. Dead wrong. Sometimes the customer is expensively, devastatingly wrong.
When I finally analyzed the real costs (something customer support consultants never tell you to do), this “valuable” client was costing me money rather than making it for me. Between overtime, stress-induced turnover, and missed opportunities, I was literally paying them for the customer experience of abuse.
The day I fired them was the day my business practices actually became profitable. Revenue dropped 35%. Profit increased 40%. Customer isn’t always right – sometimes acknowledging that the customer is wrong saves your business.
Why This Customer Service Mantra Is Destroying Businesses
Where This Toxic Myth Came From
Harry Gordon Selfridge, the famous retailer, coined this mantra in 1909. We’re running 2025 businesses on advice from when times have changed dramatically – from telegrams to AI.
Selfridge was trying to meet customer expectations in an era of “buyer beware” where shops treated customers poorly. But you’re not Selfridge. This isn’t 1909. And believing “customer is always right” without nuance is bad for business.
What Modern Business Schools Won’t Tell You
Here are the reasons why the customer myth destroys companies:
1. It Creates a Culture Where Happy Employees Become Extinct
Great customer service doesn’t mean sacrificing your team’s well-being. When you let customers berate your staff, employees see the writing on the wall. Your best people – the ones who deliver great service – leave first.
I’ve worked in customer service across continents. In my Australian manufacturing business, watching staff get berated by customers while management insisted on treating customers like royalty causes conflict between management and staff. Happy employees create happy customers, not the other way around. When you don’t know when to say no, you lose both.
2. Different Types of Customers Require Different Approaches
Not all customers deserves the same treatment. Right customers respect boundaries, pay on time, and value your product or service. But when a customer is wrong about fundamental business relationships, continuing to help the customer at any cost destroys profitability. Sometimes this means firing them. Customer may be important, but customer and the business must have mutual respect.
3. Customer Needs Versus Customer Wants
There’s a difference between legitimate customer needs and demands. Customers often confuse “service” with “servitude.” When saying that the customer deserves everything they demand, you’re not providing service quality – you’re enabling dysfunction.
The Truth: Sometimes the Customer is Wrong
Great Customer Relationships Look Different
After 30 years in business, here’s what enhance the customer experience actually means:
Professional Boundaries Create Better Experiences. Let the customer know your boundaries upfront. My best clients never expected me to violate professional standards. They understood that customer interactions work best with mutual respect. Customer wants reasonable service, delivered professionally.
Real Customer Issues Deserve Real Solutions. When facing legitimate customer issues, absolutely go above and beyond. But saying the customer is always right when they’re flat out wrong helps nobody. Customer relationships thrive on honesty, not appeasement.
The Hidden Costs of the “Always Right” Business Philosophy
Let me show you real numbers from my Australian manufacturing business that prove customer is always right doesn’t work:
Good Customer (Annual)
- Revenue: $50,000
- Service hours: 20
- Team stress: Low
- Morale impact: Positive
- Actual profit: $15,000
Unreasonable Customer (Annual)
- Revenue: $75,000
- Service hours: 200
- Team stress: Critical
- Morale impact: Devastating
- Actual profit: -$5,000 (negative)
The customer’s revenue looked better on paper, but sometimes customers cost more than they contribute. This reality check changed how I approach long-term success.
The Solution: A System That Protects Profits and People
The Three-Strike Evaluation Framework
Here’s how to identify when a customer isn’t right for your business:
Strike One: The Value Test – When customers no matter what expect discounts, they’re telling you something. A Customer like this doesn’t value your expertise. Is the customer still arguing after you’ve explained your value once? That’s strike one.
Strike Two: The Boundary Test – Set clear expectations for customer service experience:
- Response times
- Communication channels
- Revision limits
When clients repeatedly violate these after reminders, the customer isn’t always right – they’re disrespectful. Sometimes wrong is just wrong.
Strike Three: The Respect Test – Any customer who doesn’t respect your team is out. Period. It takes Employees to make your business successful, and the good ones are virtually irreplaceable. Difficult clients are not.
How Business Owners Can Fire Problem Clients Professionally
I’ve had to know when to say goodbye to numerous clients. Here’s the script:
“After reviewing our service delivery, we’ve determined we’re not the best fit to meet your needs. We want to return you to the market where another provider can better serve your requirements. We’ll ensure a smooth 30-day transition.”
This approach respects both parties while protecting your team and profits.
What Actually Happens When You Stop Believing Every Customer Is Always Right
Immediate Impact on Business Health
When I stopped believing “the customer is always right” mythology:
- Week 1: Initial revenue drop, some panic.
- Week 2: Employee morale skyrocketed and they enjoyed coming into work again.
- Week 3: Productivity increased massively.
- Week 4: Better clients appeared.
Why? Because we finally had capacity for great customer relationships instead of managing difficult ones.
Long-Term Transformation Results
Six months after implementing boundaries:
- Profit margins increased over 20%.
- Staff turnover dropped to almost nil.
- Customer satisfaction from good clients soared.
- Stress-related absences disappeared.
Many businesses discover the same truth: when you stop accommodating all customers, you can finally deliver excellence to the right ones.
The Questions Business Owners Are Asking
“Won’t This Hurt My Customer Experience Metrics?”
Only if you measure the wrong things. Customer experience isn’t about saying yes to everything. It’s about delivering consistent value to clients who appreciate it. It is not always possible to please everyone and that’s okay.
“What About Online Reviews?”
Difficult customers leave bad reviews whether you keep them or fire them. But happy customers who receive excellent service because you’re not exhausted from difficult clients? They become evangelists.
“How Do I Know When a Customer Is Wrong?”
Track these metrics:
- Revenue versus time invested
- Payment history
- Team feedback on stress levels
- Opportunity costs
If the ROI is negative, reasons why the customer should go are clear.
“I’m a startup struggling to survive. Can I really afford to fire any customer when every dollar counts?“
This is exactly when you need to be most selective. I learned this lesson the hard way in my first Australian venture – taking bad money when desperate only delays the inevitable collapse while destroying your ability to serve good customers.
Here’s the reality: If you’re spending 80% of your time on a customer who pays late, demands discounts, and exhausts your team, you literally cannot afford to keep them. That time could be spent finding three better clients. When you’re small, all customer interaction either builds or burns your business. Difficult customers don’t just cost money – they prevent you from making money.
Start with one rule: No client gets more than 30% of your time unless they generate 30% of your profit. Track this for two weeks. You’ll be shocked at what you discover. The customer is not always right when keeping them means your startup won’t survive.
“How do I handle the employee morale dynamics when I fire a difficult client they’ve been dealing with?“
This is your moment to prove you’re a leader worth following. When I fired that 35% revenue client in Australia, I gathered my team and said: “Your wellbeing matters more than any client’s money. We’re building something better.”
The key is transparency. Share the real numbers – show them how this unreasonable customer was actually costing the company money. Employees need to understand you’re not being reckless; you’re being strategic. Then immediately redirect that freed capacity toward better opportunities. Nothing boosts employee morale faster than replacing an abusive customer with a respectful one.
One warning: Some team members might panic about job security. Address this head-on. Show your pipeline, share your plan, and most importantly, involve them in pursuing better clients. They know firsthand what great customer service looks like – let them help identify and win the right customers.
“What’s my legal exposure if I terminate a customer relationship? Can they sue me?“
As a qualified barrister who’s drafted hundreds of contracts, here’s the truth: Your legal risk is higher keeping a problematic customer than firing them. Excessive demands often push you into grey areas – scope creep, verbal promises, emergency exceptions that become expectations. That’s where lawsuits breed.
Always include a termination clause in your service agreements. Mine typically reads: “Either party may terminate this agreement with 30 days written notice.” Simple. Bulletproof. No customer complaints about blindsiding.
If you don’t have contracts (fix that immediately), you still have the right to refuse service as long as you’re not discriminating based on protected categories. Complete any paid work, refund any prepayments, document everything in writing, and transition professionally. In 30 years across multiple countries, I’ve never been successfully sued for professionally ending a client relationship. But I’ve seen plenty of businesses sued by clients they should have fired.
“Won’t firing customers damage my reputation, especially in a small market where word travels fast?“
A: Here’s what damages reputation: exhausted staff delivering subpar service because they’re burnt out from unreasonable customers. Late deliveries because one client monopolizes your time. Good clients leaving because you can’t serve them properly.
Sometimes the customer you fire becomes your best marketing. They tell their equally difficult friends not to bother you, while professional clients hear you run a serious operation. The Customer isn’t always right, and the market respects businesses that know it.
Your 30-Day Action Plan
Week 1: Audit Your Client Base
- Identify which clients drain resources.
- Calculate true profitability.
- Survey team about client-related stress.
- Find your bottom 20% – they probably consume the most resources.
Week 2: Establish Boundaries
- Create service agreements.
- Define acceptable customer interactions.
- Document problem behaviors.
- Prepare transition plans.
Week 3: Communicate Changes
- Inform good clients about enhanced focus.
- Set boundaries with problem clients.
- Issue first warnings where needed.
- Line up replacement opportunities.
Week 4: Execute Decisively
- Fire the worst offender.
- Monitor team response.
- Track time savings.
- Pursue better clients.
The Uncomfortable Truth No Guru Will Tell You
Most advice about “customer always” being right comes from people who’ve never run a real business. They’ve never dealt with customer support nightmares or calculated the real cost of accommodation without limits.
I have. Across multiple continents and industries. And I’m telling you straight: The customer is not always right. Often, they’re expensively, destructively wrong.
Your business exists to solve problems profitably, not to accommodate excessive demands that destroy your team and margins.
Summary: Pain Points Solved, Myths Busted, Profits Protected
Pain Points We’ve Addressed:
- Unreasonable customer demands? Use the three-strike system.
- Destroyed morale? Protect your people, watch productivity soar.
- Wasted resources? The audit process identifies problem clients.
- Review threats? Happy customers matter more than difficult ones.
- Constant discounts? Stop negotiating with those who don’t value you.
- Team burnout? Some clients are unpleasable – stop trying.
The Business Heretic’s Truth: The Customer is not always right. The RIGHT customer is always valuable. Know the difference, act on it, and watch your business transform from a customer service charity into a profitable enterprise.
Sometimes customers are wrong. Acknowledge it. Act on it. Build a business that serves people who value what you offer.
That’s not heresy. That’s just good business from someone who’s learned it the expensive way.
Ready to transform your client base from liability to asset?
Join the Business Heretic newsletter and get first access to my upcoming eBook that expands on everything in this article. You’ll discover “The Customer Detox Blueprint” – my complete system for professionally separating from difficult customers while strengthening relationships with profitable ones.
What you’ll get in the full guide:
- The complete three-strike evaluation framework with scoring worksheets
- Word-for-word scripts for every difficult conversation
- Contract templates that prevent problem clients from the start
- 30-60-90 day transition timelines for different business types
- Industry-specific strategies (B2B, B2C, service, product)
- Financial worksheets to calculate true customer profitability
- Team morale assessment tools
Newsletter subscribers get:
- 25% discount when the eBook launches
- Weekly heretical business insights before I publish them anywhere else
- First access to all new content and tools
Because life’s too short to let bad customers ruin your business.
No spam. No fluff. Just battle-tested business heresy delivered weekly. Unsubscribe anytime.
